Richard Prince - Cosby Challenges Wash Post.
Cosby Challenges Washington Post
July 19, 2006
Activists Say "Black Man" Portrayals Ignore a CrisisBill Cosby, the star speaker on a panel of experts, lambasted the Washington Post Tuesday for its continuing "Being a Black Man" series as painting too upbeat a picture.
Kaiser forum came complete with logo.
"I'm not interested in hearing that things aren't as bad as they seem. They're horrible," Cosby said at "Paths to Success: A Forum on Young African-American Men," sponsored by the Kaiser Family Foundation, the Post and Harvard University.
The three groups jointly conducted a survey that, in June, began the Post series.
Among other findings, eight in 10 black men said they were satisfied with their lives, and six in 10 reported that it was a "good time" to be a black man in the United States.
That sentiment – and an opening series of video sound bites from black men in Washington – first drew Cosby's wrath.
"The Washington Post ran a clip and then they edited it and they had in what they wanted us to see these men saying," he said. "Unless I missed it, I heard not one black man say anything about being a father. I heard not one black man say, 'my responsibility,' not one. The edited version of these people with a camera on a drive-by – I'm looking to media. I don't like people who see and can't tell the truth. . . . A man tells me, 'It's not as bad as it seems.' I don't want to hear that shit."
Cosby, who with the others spoke at Kaiser's offices in downtown Washington in a presentation transmitted over the Internet, also blasted the paper over its initial coverage of his May 2004 remarks that set off his two-year crusade to address black personal responsibility. What wasn't reported, Cosby said, were his comments that "our children were trying to tell us something and we're not listening." He similarly criticized the Atlanta Journal-Constitution.
The actor, comedian, activist and holder of a doctor of education degree, consistently addressed as "Dr. Cosby" by moderator Charles Ogletree of Harvard Law School, became exasperated when Steven A. Holmes, a Post national news editor, said the series would not resume until the fall.
"How can you take off the summer?" Cosby asked, saying that is when young people can be idle and angry. "Don't you have some junior people who would love to" step in?
"I'm holding the Atlanta Journal-Constitution and the Washington Post – all the white newspapers – to look at us and take us seriously. You had your Judas who reported Jesse Jackson saying Hymietown," he said, referring to Post reporter Milton Coleman's quoting of Jackson's reference to Jews as "Hymie" and to New York as "Hymietown" in an informal conversation during Jackson's 1984 presidential campaign.
Philip Bennett, the Post's managing editor, told Journal-isms today:
"I think Bill Cosby was confusing our ongoing coverage of issues affecting African Americans in the Washington region, which we are committed to pursuing on an ongoing basis, and the next round of profiles of individuals in this series. He was also making a rhetorical point about the urgent need to cover the problems he was discussing, which we recognize.
"The profiles take months to develop and we are in the reporting phase for the next round. That's why they'll resume in the fall. One of the reasons that we've organized the series this way is to learn as we go. We learned some important things at the Kaiser-Post conference that we'll apply to future stories."
At bottom, the conflict over the series was in large part over which view of black men should be presented. It was a role reversal, considering that activists have long argued that the media choose to emphasize the negative.
Even though most speakers did not mention the Post series, their repeated warnings about an emergency among African Americans contrasted with the assertion that 70 percent of black men said they were doing fine.
"When you have 30 percent of any population group in trouble, it's a crisis," agreed the Post's Holmes. "I have no argument about that. But it gives a distorted picture of black men" to focus only on the 30 percent. "Accuracy is what we should strive for," Holmes told the group. "My responsibility is to present the truth whatever that truth is."
Replied Cosby, "The 30 percent that's not" doing well "could shoot some of the 70 percent."
Mayor-elect Ron Dellums of Oakland, Calif., the former congressman, added later, "What is accurate?" citing varying perspectives on accuracy and the need for context. "Don't just say 'accurate,' but be accurate in a way that mobilizes people to deal with the problems of black males in America, because they're being ground up like glass."
Many of the panelists agreed that the real problem was the black family. Dr. Alvin Poussaint of Harvard Medical School pointed to a Yale study that showed that black males were expelled at twice the rate of others in pre-school, and that "young black males are much more likely to show up with internal problems," such as attention deficit disorder and dyslexia. He said there were "very high levels of child abuse and neglect in the black community," and that produces an early anger.
That speaks to the decline of black families and in appropriate parenting, speakers contended.
Larry Levitt, the Kaiser foundation's vice president for communications, said Kaiser did not yet know how many watched the Webcast, "though we do know that it was more traffic than we've ever had (including for some very high profile webcasts), and enough to overwhelm and crash our servers for a time."
C-SPAN taped the event. A C-SPAN spokeswoman said she did not yet know when it would air.
July 19, 2006
Activists Say "Black Man" Portrayals Ignore a CrisisBill Cosby, the star speaker on a panel of experts, lambasted the Washington Post Tuesday for its continuing "Being a Black Man" series as painting too upbeat a picture.
Kaiser forum came complete with logo.
"I'm not interested in hearing that things aren't as bad as they seem. They're horrible," Cosby said at "Paths to Success: A Forum on Young African-American Men," sponsored by the Kaiser Family Foundation, the Post and Harvard University.
The three groups jointly conducted a survey that, in June, began the Post series.
Among other findings, eight in 10 black men said they were satisfied with their lives, and six in 10 reported that it was a "good time" to be a black man in the United States.
That sentiment – and an opening series of video sound bites from black men in Washington – first drew Cosby's wrath.
"The Washington Post ran a clip and then they edited it and they had in what they wanted us to see these men saying," he said. "Unless I missed it, I heard not one black man say anything about being a father. I heard not one black man say, 'my responsibility,' not one. The edited version of these people with a camera on a drive-by – I'm looking to media. I don't like people who see and can't tell the truth. . . . A man tells me, 'It's not as bad as it seems.' I don't want to hear that shit."
Cosby, who with the others spoke at Kaiser's offices in downtown Washington in a presentation transmitted over the Internet, also blasted the paper over its initial coverage of his May 2004 remarks that set off his two-year crusade to address black personal responsibility. What wasn't reported, Cosby said, were his comments that "our children were trying to tell us something and we're not listening." He similarly criticized the Atlanta Journal-Constitution.
The actor, comedian, activist and holder of a doctor of education degree, consistently addressed as "Dr. Cosby" by moderator Charles Ogletree of Harvard Law School, became exasperated when Steven A. Holmes, a Post national news editor, said the series would not resume until the fall.
"How can you take off the summer?" Cosby asked, saying that is when young people can be idle and angry. "Don't you have some junior people who would love to" step in?
"I'm holding the Atlanta Journal-Constitution and the Washington Post – all the white newspapers – to look at us and take us seriously. You had your Judas who reported Jesse Jackson saying Hymietown," he said, referring to Post reporter Milton Coleman's quoting of Jackson's reference to Jews as "Hymie" and to New York as "Hymietown" in an informal conversation during Jackson's 1984 presidential campaign.
Philip Bennett, the Post's managing editor, told Journal-isms today:
"I think Bill Cosby was confusing our ongoing coverage of issues affecting African Americans in the Washington region, which we are committed to pursuing on an ongoing basis, and the next round of profiles of individuals in this series. He was also making a rhetorical point about the urgent need to cover the problems he was discussing, which we recognize.
"The profiles take months to develop and we are in the reporting phase for the next round. That's why they'll resume in the fall. One of the reasons that we've organized the series this way is to learn as we go. We learned some important things at the Kaiser-Post conference that we'll apply to future stories."
At bottom, the conflict over the series was in large part over which view of black men should be presented. It was a role reversal, considering that activists have long argued that the media choose to emphasize the negative.
Even though most speakers did not mention the Post series, their repeated warnings about an emergency among African Americans contrasted with the assertion that 70 percent of black men said they were doing fine.
"When you have 30 percent of any population group in trouble, it's a crisis," agreed the Post's Holmes. "I have no argument about that. But it gives a distorted picture of black men" to focus only on the 30 percent. "Accuracy is what we should strive for," Holmes told the group. "My responsibility is to present the truth whatever that truth is."
Replied Cosby, "The 30 percent that's not" doing well "could shoot some of the 70 percent."
Mayor-elect Ron Dellums of Oakland, Calif., the former congressman, added later, "What is accurate?" citing varying perspectives on accuracy and the need for context. "Don't just say 'accurate,' but be accurate in a way that mobilizes people to deal with the problems of black males in America, because they're being ground up like glass."
Many of the panelists agreed that the real problem was the black family. Dr. Alvin Poussaint of Harvard Medical School pointed to a Yale study that showed that black males were expelled at twice the rate of others in pre-school, and that "young black males are much more likely to show up with internal problems," such as attention deficit disorder and dyslexia. He said there were "very high levels of child abuse and neglect in the black community," and that produces an early anger.
That speaks to the decline of black families and in appropriate parenting, speakers contended.
Larry Levitt, the Kaiser foundation's vice president for communications, said Kaiser did not yet know how many watched the Webcast, "though we do know that it was more traffic than we've ever had (including for some very high profile webcasts), and enough to overwhelm and crash our servers for a time."
C-SPAN taped the event. A C-SPAN spokeswoman said she did not yet know when it would air.
posted by J.C. "Fanz23" Lewis, Jr | 9:22 AM
<< Home